Academic Medicine Open Forum

 View Only

Avoiding unconscious bias in letters of recommendation

  • 1.  Avoiding unconscious bias in letters of recommendation

    Posted 08-16-2020 12:44:00 PM

    Whether you are writing a recommendation letter for a student applying to medical school or residency, a colleague considered for a promotion, or a former employee seeking a new job, your intent to convey praise can inadvertently convey bias and evoke stereotypes—especially about people of color. Keep this advice in mind:

     

    1. Consider your bias, no matter who you are – even letter authors of color are susceptible to allowing implicit bias to creep in.
    2. Emphasize qualifications and achievements – give concrete examples of success
    3. Take time to write a long, substantial letter – brevity can be interpreted as a lack of interest in candidate’s success
    4. Don’t hold back or qualify praise – ringing endorsement is better than minimal assurances or backhanded praise
    5. Accomplishments speak louder than effort – bias creeps in when noting how a candidate has overcome limitations or when hard work is emphasized without mention of accomplishments
    6. Think hard before sharing personal information – information not pertinent to the application can expose details that the candidate might not want to share (i.e., DACA status or socioeconomic background)
    7. Don’t evoke stereotypes – such as mentioning a candidate’s English proficiency or how “surprising their performance is, given their circumstances”
    8. Be careful with your adjectives – in order to focus on accomplishments over effort, select words like “successful” and “insightful” over words like “compassionate” and “hardworking”

     

    -curated from The Muse



    ------------------------------
    David Acosta
    Chief Diversity and Inclusion Officer
    Association of American Medical Colleges
    ------------------------------