Academic Medicine Open Forum

 View Only

Counseling Students for STEP 1 Pass-Fail Change

  • 1.  Counseling Students for STEP 1 Pass-Fail Change

    Posted 12-10-2020 09:17:00 AM
    Good morning,

    In recent weeks, several of our class leaders in the CO 2024 have come forward seeking more guidance around the transition of STEP 1 to Pass-Fail.  Specifically, "the unknown of when to take STEP 1  continues to be a major concern among many of [their] classmates".  

    Some students who have not struggled academically are even considering writing STEP 1  early (November/December) while still in the preclerkship courses to secure a number score, while others are struggling with the fact if they should wait and just post a "pass".  

    And we similarly have no idea what program directors will do with a number of residency applicants who post a score compared to those who do not.  Is there an advantage to posting a score in this scenario?  

    I am interested in any discussions that have been occurring through the AAMC/USMLE about when schools might expect black-out dates for testing due to the transition and I am interested in how any other schools with 18-month pre-clerkship curriculum are counseling students about when to write for STEP 1.  

    Thank you. 
    Mark Beard


    ------------------------------
    Mark Beard
    Associate Dean of Medical Education
    University of South Dakota
    ------------------------------